My Pal, the Ancient Philosopher

(nautil.us)

26 points | by HR01 4 hours ago ago

4 comments

  • keybored 4 minutes ago

    I skimmed parts of The Closing of the American Mind. For a Culture War classic you wouldnā€™t think it would spend so much time with philosophers. But it does. Itā€™s kind of introverted, considering what itā€™s famous for. And it does feel like heā€™s constantly coming back to his four or so invisible friends.

    Same with some other philosopher scholars. A problem presents itself: how would Alexis confront this? Well letā€™s consider that time when he was...

    It can be invigorating to read some ā€œancientā€ author and find out that they are 99% the same person as you are. But that means reading them. Not reading five-times removed sources on them.

  • tyrust 3 hours ago

    Thematically related recent piece about how Machiavelli and Du Bois had a similar perspective: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42127895

    Also, early this year I read Pigliucci's How to Be a Stoic. In that book the author often references that he had "conversations" with his "friend" Epictetus.

    All this to say: there might be something to this practice of befriending the dead.

  • pedroigor91 3 hours ago

    This philosopher's name wouldn't work in Brazil...

    • the-chitmonger 2 hours ago

      I tried looking up what Mengzi might mean in Brazil (or alternatively, in Portuguese) and couldn't find anything. Would you mind elaborating?